top of page

Why do I shut down in conflict?

Writer: Chantal Esperanza
Chantal Esperanza
May 7
3 min read

Updated: Nov 1

Person sitting quietly during a conversation while internally thinking of words they wish they could express

Many people do not shut down in every difficult conversation. It tends to happen in particular moments, with particular people, or when a certain tone enters the room. Afterwards, there can be frustration, replaying what you wish you had said, and a promise that next time will be different. Then the next disagreement arrives and the words do not come.


If you have been asking yourself, "Why do I shut down in conflict?", the answer often lies in what your body has learned about conflict over time.


Why do I go quiet when someone is upset with me?


Conflict can register as a threat even when the current situation is safe. A raised voice, a sharp tone, or a certain look may echo earlier experiences where disagreement led to anger, unpredictability, or someone pulling away.


When that happens, the body can move into a freeze response. Thoughts become harder to reach. Words feel far away. Some people describe feeling as though they have left the conversation while still sitting in it.


The Gottman Institute calls this state flooding, and describes freezing and going quiet as some of the ways it shows up.


Why can't I say how I feel in the moment?


Often, there is a lot happening internally. Part of you may want to speak up. Another part may be working hard to keep things calm. Holding both at once can be overwhelming.


This is especially common for people who took on the role of peacemaker growing up. Setting your own needs aside to keep the household steady may once have been the safest option available. In adult relationships, that same strategy can leave important feelings unspoken.


Going quiet can also be protective. If conflict has escalated quickly in the past, silence may feel like a way to keep things from getting worse.


How does shutting down affect a relationship?


Silence can reduce tension in the moment, and it can also leave issues unresolved. When one partner tends to pursue and the other tends to withdraw, both can end up feeling unheard. A review of 74 studies found this demand and withdraw cycle was linked to lower relationship satisfaction for both partners.


Recognizing your part in the cycle is about understanding, not blame. It gives both people more information about what is happening between them.


How can I stay present during hard conversations?


A few small practices can create more room in these moments.


  • Notice what is happening in your body. Naming it to yourself, such as "I am feeling overwhelmed," can slow things down.

  • Speak from your own experience. Saying "I am finding it hard to think right now" lets the other person know what is happening without placing blame.

  • Take a pause when you need one. Let the other person know you want to come back to the conversation, and agree on when. The Gottman Institute suggests a break of about 20 to 30 minutes before checking whether you are ready to continue.

  • Return and name what matters. Once you feel steadier, share what you need, whether that is to feel heard, respected, or understood.


When this pattern keeps repeating


If shutting down happens often, it can help to explore where the pattern began and what would help you feel safer in difficult conversations. This work often happens in individual counselling, and in couples counselling when both partners want to change how conflict unfolds between them.


The things that matter most are often the hardest to say. Learning to stay present, even a little longer each time, can help you bring those things into your relationships.



Chantal Esperanza, Registered Clinical Counsellor at OP Counselling Services

About Chantal

Chantal Esperanza is a Registered Clinical Counsellor and associate counsellor at OP Counselling Services. She works with adults and couples navigating trauma, addiction, relational distress, and the experiences that can make trust, safety, and connection feel complicated. Her work is grounded in attachment science, interpersonal neurobiology, EMDR, and Internal Family Systems.



Comments


get in touch

Reach out when you're ready

Send us a note and our team will get back to you within one business day. We offer sessions in person in East Vancouver and online across BC. Everything you share stays confidential.

bottom of page